Best Family Doctors in Mattoon
Finding the right family doctor in Mattoon means weighing insurance coverage, distance, and bedside manner. The metro has a growing bench of family doctors — 74+ verified family doctors are listed below.
74 family doctors in Mattoon



Shelbi N Birch, APRN
4.5Shelbi N Birch · Family Nurse Practitioner
1004 Health Center Dr Suite 100(217) 238-3435
Taylor Johnson, MSN, APRN, FNP BC
4.5Taylor Johnson · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 204(217) 258-4155
Kara Michelle Painton, APN
4.5Kara Michelle Painton · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 120(217) 258-7590
Rachel Elaine Walton, APN
4.5Rachel Elaine Walton · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr(217) 258-7590
Rebekah Lyn Gaffin, FNP
4.5Rebekah Lyn Gaffin · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Drive(217) 258-5900
Ashley K Tennill, APN
4.5Ashley K Tennill · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4325
Jenna M Vogel, APRN, FNP C
4.5Jenna M Vogel · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4019
Christa Lynne Metzelaars, NP C
4.5Christa Lynne Metzelaars · Family Nurse Practitioner
911 Remington Rd Suite B(217) 234-3091
Nichole Lee Denton, FNP
4.5Nichole Lee Denton · Family Nurse Practitioner
1019 Charleston Ave E(217) 508-4940
Jeanelle Y Murphy, DO
4.5Jeanelle Y Murphy · Family Medicine Physician
200 Richmond Ave E Suite 2(217) 234-7000
Amanda Zumbahlen, APN
4.5Amanda Zumbahlen · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-3000
Jennifer Derrickson, APRN
4.5Jennifer Derrickson · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr(217) 258-5900
Sydney L Shackelford, FNP
4.5Sydney L Shackelford · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 258-2440
Kelli Lynn Blagg, FNP APN
4.5Kelli Lynn Blagg · Family Nurse Practitioner
10555 East County Road 800 N(217) 235-4227
Angela Marie Brumleve, APRN
4.5Angela Marie Brumleve · Family Nurse Practitioner
1005 Health Center Dr(217) 258-2581
Dominic Perrino, DO
4.5Dominic Perrino · Family Medicine Physician
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4325
Kristine Ross Carpenter, MD
4.5Kristine Ross Carpenter · Family Medicine Physician
2512 Hurst Dr.(217) 258-5900
Caroline Bierman, APRN
4.5Caroline Bierman · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4960
Lori A. Nottmeyer, APN
4.5Lori A. Nottmeyer · Family Nurse Practitioner
200 Richmond Ave E(217) 234-7000

Kelley L Grewell, APRN
4.5Kelley L Grewell · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 201(217) 258-4030
Kristina Nicole Smith, APRN,FNP C
4.5Kristina Nicole Smith · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-3000

Robert C Atchley, APN
4.5Robert C Atchley · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 258-2551

Mallory Bolander, APRN
4.5Mallory Bolander · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4019
Nicole Y Ottens, DO
4.5Nicole Y Ottens · Family Medicine Physician
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 258-2551
Laura H Hardiek, APRN
4.5Laura H Hardiek · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 258-2551
Jessica Skidmore, APRN
4.5Jessica Skidmore · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4325
Christine M Banks, APRN
4.5Christine M Banks · Family Nurse Practitioner
3029 N County Road 330E(217) 276-2897
Lucas L Catt, MD
4.5Lucas L Catt · Family Medicine Physician
1005 Health Center Dr Suite 103(217) 258-4051

Taylee Eldridge, APN
4.5Taylee Eldridge · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 107(217) 258-4096
Margaret Louisa Tate, DO
4.5Margaret Louisa Tate · Family Medicine Physician
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 120(217) 258-5900
Katie Michelle O'Halloran, FNP BC
4.5Katie Michelle O'Halloran · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4960
Michaela K Frey, APRN
4.5Michaela K Frey · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-3000
Jeffrey J Jenson, MD
4.5Jeffrey J Jenson · Family Medicine Physician
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 302(217) 238-4850

Lana Keigley
4.5Lana Keigley · Family Nurse Practitioner
1005 Health Center Dr Suite 100(217) 258-4006

Cody J Meyer, APRN
4.5Cody J Meyer · Family Nurse Practitioner
1005 Health Center Dr Suite 100(217) 258-4006
Debbie Murray, APRN
4.5Debbie Murray · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 401(217) 258-4020
Matthew James Dorner, MD
4.5Matthew James Dorner · Family Medicine Physician
3555 E Cr 250N(864) 580-1676
Sergio M. Rodriguez, MD
4.5Sergio M. Rodriguez · Family Medicine Physician
1000 Health Center Drive(217) 238-4325
Robert Wochner, MD
4.5Robert Wochner · Family Medicine Physician
1005 Health Center Drive(217) 258-4051
Tiffany M Toney, APRN, CNP
4.5Tiffany M Toney · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 130(217) 258-7590

Ashley Adams, APRN
4.5Ashley Adams · Family Nurse Practitioner
1004 Health Center Dr Suite 100(217) 238-3435

Tory L. Keefer, FNP
4.5Tory L. Keefer · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 130(217) 258-5900
Chelsea Caye Pugh
4.5Chelsea Caye Pugh · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 201(172) 584-0302
Ashley Nicole Huddlestun, FNP BC
4.5Ashley Nicole Huddlestun · Family Nurse Practitioner
911 Remington Rd Suite B(217) 234-3091
Kimberly Lynn Pruemer, APRN
4.5Kimberly Lynn Pruemer · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-3000
Kristy Dawn Shafer, NP
4.5Kristy Dawn Shafer · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 107(217) 258-4096
Bella Family Health And Wellness, LLC
4.5Bella Family Health And Wellness, LLC · Family Nurse Practitioner
10555 E County Road 800N(217) 235-4227
Traci Sumer Knierim, NP
4.5Traci Sumer Knierim · Family Medicine Physician
420 Broadway Ave E(217) 512-1370
Matthew Henry Newton, DO
4.5Matthew Henry Newton · Family Medicine Physician
2512 Hurst Dr(217) 258-5900
Jagan Mohan Reddy Bokka, MD
4.5Jagan Mohan Reddy Bokka · Family Medicine Physician
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4325

Emily N Hardiek, NP
4.5Emily N Hardiek · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 130(217) 258-5900
Michelle M Mathews, APN
4.5Michelle M Mathews · Family Nurse Practitioner
1005 Health Center Dr(217) 258-4051
Rebecca Eugenia Sparks, ANP
4.5Rebecca Eugenia Sparks · Family Nurse Practitioner
2512 Hurst Dr Suite 120(217) 258-7590

Danielle Nicole Walker, MD
4.5Danielle Nicole Walker · Family Medicine Physician
200 Richmond Ave E Suite 2(217) 234-7000
Eliza J Smith, NP
4.5Eliza J Smith · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-3000
Central Illinois Family Health Center
4.5Central Illinois Family Health Center · Family Nurse Practitioner
10555 East County Rd 800 North(217) 235-4227

Jessica Ann Prince, NP
4.5Jessica Ann Prince · Family Nurse Practitioner
1201 Wooddell Way Suite B(217) 238-2030
Stacy L. Ordner, APN
4.5Stacy L. Ordner · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4325
Andrew Robert Gage, MD
4.5Andrew Robert Gage · Family Medicine Physician
101 Coles Centre Dr(217) 234-5110
Jill Thompson, FNP C
4.5Jill Thompson · Family Nurse Practitioner
1000 Health Center Dr Suite 107(217) 258-4096
Lyndsay Chevalier, APN
4.5Lyndsay Chevalier · Family Nurse Practitioner
1004 Health Center Dr(217) 238-4774
Family Doctors in Mattoon by insurance
These providers list this insurance as accepted, but coverage should be confirmed directly with the provider before booking.
Family Doctors in nearby cities
Same specialty in cities near Mattoon — useful if your insurance network extends across the metro.
About finding a family doctor in Mattoon
Mattoon has family doctors practicing across hospital systems, group practices, and independent clinics. When choosing a family doctor in Mattoon, the three factors most patients care about are: insurance acceptance, distance from home or work, and patient reviews. Heallexa shows all three on every listing so you can compare without clicking back and forth.
Many Mattoon family doctors list major insurance plans including Blue Cross Blue Shield, Aetna, UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, Humana, and Medicare. Listings reflect what providers have indicated they accept — always confirm in-network status directly with the office before booking. Out-of-network visits can cost 3–5× more than in-network ones.
Common questions about family doctors in Mattoon
How do I find the highest-rated family doctor in Mattoon?+
Sort the list above by rating. Heallexa surfaces verified patient reviews alongside credentials so you can see whether a provider's strengths match what you actually need.
What if no Mattoon family doctors accept my insurance?+
Try the surrounding metro — insurance networks often extend across multiple cities. The nearby-cities links below open the same specialty in adjacent markets. Always confirm coverage directly with the provider.
Are walk-in visits available with Mattoon family doctors?+
Walk-ins are uncommon for most family doctors. The "available today" filter shows providers with open same-day slots.
How often is this Mattoon list updated?+
Heallexa refreshes provider data from public NPI records and license databases on a rolling basis. Listings that fall out of the active registry are removed automatically.